Diff for "Campaign Selection Vote, 2021"

Differences between revisions 8 and 9

This page describes the results of HICU-RPG's vote on the next campaign the group will play. Although HICU-RPG has often chosen what campaign to play based on player voting, the 2021 vote is the first in which the candidate campaigns were determined by an open proposal process.

12 campaigns were proposed:

Campaign	Setting	GM
Deus Machina	Fantasy/Bunworld	Matthew
Beyond the Twelve Worlds	Scifi/BTW	Bryce
Mares in Chains	Fantasy/Pony	Jelle
Avatar	Fantasy/Avatar	swicked
Dread Dimensions	Pony/PRPG	Winston
On Shaky Wings	Fantasy/Imp-erium	Matthew
Philosophical Magic	Fantasy/PM	Bryce
Old Bones	Scifi/BTF	Matthew
Afterward	Scifi/Nonsanc	Bryce
Pink Fox Down	Scifi/BTF	Matthew
The Lost ME	Fantasy/Usiren	Bryce
Star Prism Squad	Scifi/Gems	Matthew

Results

1st Place / Winner	Avatar
2nd Place	Lost Me
3rd Place	Beyond the Twelve Worlds
4th Place	Deus Machina
5th Place	Philosophical Magic
-	Nonsanc: Afterward
7th Place	Dread Dimensions
-	Old Bones
9th Place	Pink Fox Down
--	On Shaky Wings
11th Place	Star Prism Squad
12th Place	Mares in Chains

The voting system used was cloneproof Schwartz sequential dropping, i.e. Schulze Voting, which satisfies the Condorcet criterion; in the event of a tie, the tie will be broken by comparing the Borda Count of the candidates.

Enthusiasm Data

This data is about how voters marked their enthusiasm about the proposed campaigns. It is non-binding with respect to campaign choice, but is here for feedback for GM-candidates. (It is the prerogative of a GM candidate to choose to withdraw a candidate campaign from consideration after voting closes, in which case the next runner up would be selected.)

Campaign	Would Not Play	Uninterested	Somewhat Enthusiastic	Very Enthusiastic
The Lost ME	0%	0%	50%	50%
Deus Machina	0%	12%	38%	50%
Avatar	0%	12%	38%	50%
Beyond the Twelve Worlds	0%	12%	62%	25%
Afterward	0%	25%	50%	25%
Philosophical Magic	12%	25%	25%	38%
Dread Dimensions	0%	38%	38%	25%
Pink Fox Down	0%	38%	50%	12%
Old Bones	0%	50%	25%	25%
On Shaky Wings	0%	62%	25%	12%
Star Prism Squad	12%	38%	38%	12%
Mares in Chains	12%	38%	50%	0%

Votes on Campaign Length

In the event that one of the campaigns below is selected, the voters' preferences for campaign length were collected on the ballot, and are found below.

Campaign	Long Campaign Desired?
Beyond the Twelve Worlds	63%
Philosophical Magic	63%
Afterward	38%
The Lost ME	75%

Alternate Voting System Results

These are non-binding, but presented for interest.

Instant Runoff

Winner: Avatar. Runner up: Dread Dimensions. Third place: Philosophical Magic.

Borda Count

Borda Count:
0: Avatar 74 (WINNER)
1: Lost Me 68
2: Deus Machina 66
3: Beyond the Twelve Worlds 66
4: Dread Dimensions 57
5: Philosophical Magic 57
6: Afterward 53
7: Old Bones 50
8: Pink Fox Down 41
9: On Shaky Wings 37
10: Star Prism Squad 29
11: Mares in Chains 26

First Past the Post (Plurality)

This is the conventional system of voting used for most US elections (which is only good for two candidates due to the presence of a "spoiler effect.")

First past the post (plurality):
   50% - Avatar (WINNER)
   12% - Philosophical Magic
   12% - On Shaky Wings
   12% - Lost Me
   12% - Dread Dimensions

-  ⇤ ← Revision 8 as of 2021-10-28 18:47:16 → 
  Size: 2798
  Editor: Bryce
  Comment:
+   ← Revision 9 as of 2021-10-30 05:16:19 → ⇥
  Size: 3753
  Editor: Bryce
  Comment:
-Deletions are marked like this.
+Additions are marked like this.
 Line 21:
- (Will be released 0200 eastern time, 2021-10-30)
-Line 23:
+Line 22:
-||1st Place / Winner|| TBD ||
||2nd Place|| TBD ||
||3rd Place|| TBD ||
||4th Place|| TBD ||
||5th Place|| TBD ||
||6th Place|| TBD ||
||7th Place|| TBD ||
||8th Place|| TBD ||
||9th Place|| TBD ||
||10th Place|| TBD ||
||11th Place|| TBD ||
||12th Place|| TBD ||
+||1st Place / Winner|| Avatar ||
||2nd Place|| Lost Me ||
||3rd Place|| Beyond the Twelve Worlds ||
|| 4th Place || Deus Machina ||
||5th Place|| Philosophical Magic ||
|| - || Nonsanc: Afterward ||
||7th Place|| Dread Dimensions ||
|| - || Old Bones ||
||9th Place|| Pink Fox Down||
|| -- || On Shaky Wings ||
||11th Place|| Star Prism Squad||
||12th Place|| Mares in Chains ||
-Line 36:
+Line 35:
-The voting system used is cloneproof Schwartz sequential dropping, i.e. [[https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.02973|Schulze Voting]], which satisfies the Condorcet criterion; in the event of a tie, the tie will be broken by comparing the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borda_count|Borda Count]] of the tied candidates.
+The voting system used was cloneproof Schwartz sequential dropping, i.e. Schulze Voting, which satisfies the Condorcet criterion; in the event of a tie, the tie will be broken by comparing the Borda Count of the candidates.
-Line 41:
+Line 40:
-||Campaign||Would Not Play||Unenthusiastic||Somewhat Enthusiastic||Very Enthusiastic||
||Deus Machina|| % || % || % || % ||
||Beyond the Twelve Worlds|| % || % || % || % ||
||Mares in Chains|| % || % || % || % ||
||Avatar|| % || % || % || % ||
||Dread Dimensions|| % || % || % || % ||
||On Shaky Wings|| % || % || % || % ||
||Philosophical Magic|| % || % || % || % ||
||Old Bones|| % || % || % || % ||
||Afterward|| % || % || % || % ||
||Pink Fox Down|| % || % || % || % ||
||The Lost ME|| % || % || % || % ||
||Star Prism Squad|| % || % || % || % ||
+||Campaign||Would Not Play||Uninterested||Somewhat Enthusiastic||Very Enthusiastic||
||The Lost ME|| 0% || 0% || 50% || 50% ||
||Deus Machina|| 0% || 12% || 38% || 50% ||
||Avatar|| 0% || 12% || 38% || 50% ||
||Beyond the Twelve Worlds|| 0% || 12% || 62% || 25% ||
||Afterward|| 0% || 25% || 50% || 25% ||
||Philosophical Magic|| 12% || 25% || 25% || 38% ||
||Dread Dimensions|| 0% || 38% || 38% || 25% ||
||Pink Fox Down|| 0% || 38% || 50% || 12% ||
||Old Bones|| 0% || 50% || 25% || 25% ||
||On Shaky Wings|| 0% || 62% || 25% || 12% ||
||Star Prism Squad|| 12% || 38% || 38% || 12% ||
||Mares in Chains|| 12% || 38% || 50% || 0% ||
-Line 59:
+Line 58:
-||Beyond the Twelve Worlds|| % ||
||Philosophical Magic|| % ||
||Afterward|| % ||
||The Lost ME|| % ||
+||Beyond the Twelve Worlds|| 63% ||
||Philosophical Magic|| 63% ||
||Afterward|| 38% ||
||The Lost ME|| 75% ||

== Alternate Voting System Results ==

These are non-binding, but presented for interest.

=== Instant Runoff ===
Winner: Avatar. Runner up: Dread Dimensions. Third place: Philosophical Magic.

=== Borda Count ===


{{{
Borda Count:
0: Avatar 74 (WINNER)
1: Lost Me 68
2: Deus Machina 66
3: Beyond the Twelve Worlds 66
4: Dread Dimensions 57
5: Philosophical Magic 57
6: Afterward 53
7: Old Bones 50
8: Pink Fox Down 41
9: On Shaky Wings 37
10: Star Prism Squad 29
11: Mares in Chains 26
}}}

=== First Past the Post (Plurality) ===

This is the conventional system of voting used for most US elections (which is only good for two candidates due to the presence of a "spoiler effect.")
{{{
First past the post (plurality):
   50% - Avatar (WINNER)
   12% - Philosophical Magic
   12% - On Shaky Wings
   12% - Lost Me
   12% - Dread Dimensions
}}}